Wednesday, 2 December 2009

Honeymoon over for Strachan at 'Boro?

After a month in charge at Middlesbrough, without a win, it seems that the problems and issues that dogged Gordon Strachan at Celtic have followed him to Teeside.

For a team with just three married men in their squad the end of the honeymoon is an inappropriate term to use but there doesn't seem much evidence of love-in's going on around the Riverside Stadium as new relationships develop.

Reading through an opinion piece in the Daily Mail the writer seemed to identify and highlight a number of issues which will be very familiar to most Celtic fans.

Touching on the problems of finding the right combination of strikers to put the ball in the net through inconsistent team selections and onto his contempt for media duties it reads like deja vu from the moans and groans of Celtic supporters over the last few years.

Throw in a fall-out with the teams most creative player, in this case Adam Johnson, and it seems that football at the Riverside isn't much fun at the moment.

PROMOTION
Without a win in the four games that Strachan has been in charge for 'Boro travel to face QPR at the weekend with their hopes of automatic promotion fading fast.

The appointment of a new manager is supposed to give a team a lift but it seems that Strachan has had a negative effect on the squad at the Riverside Stadium with his approach and attitude rubbing people up the wrong way.

Gareth Southgate managed to survive relegation last season and had the club in a decent position when he was axed although a three consecutive home defeats, including a 5-0 hammering from West Brom had attendances plummeting.

"The form of Adam Johnson since Southgate's departure and the appointment of Strachan should already set the alarm bells ringing," sounds a little familiar as we approach the first anniversary of the spectacular fall out of Strachan and Aiden McGeady.

Johnson was voted the North-East Player of the Year last week but with his mentor Southgate no longer at the club it looks certain that the academy graduate will be leaving the club at the end of the season when his contract expires.

"They cannot hold on to leads, they are shipping goals and failing to create enough chances to bury weaker opponents and, even with Strachan's new striking additions, are not scoring enough goals," added the article, if it wasn't for the date that comment could have applied to Celtic at any point from January 3 onwards to the final goal-less draws that saw the SPL title lost.

MEDIA
Finally it's onto media relations and it doesn't seem that Gordon has learned much from his Celtic experience.

Sure there can be silly questions, and even sillier questioners, but when the cameras and tapes are rolling it's a good idea to view the bigger picture and appreciate that you are talking to your supporters and the public in general rather than the dirty dozen sitting with you in the room.

The article added: "Strachan gives the impression that press conferences and interviews - in fact the media full stop - are an irrelevance, a pain in the backside and a waste of his valuable time.

"Why does anyone want to be asked and then have to answer stupid questions?

"But supporters in this region expect a little more from their managers. They want to hear what they have to say, in fact they demand it."

As I said it all sounds very familiar to the latter days of his Celtic reign, that wonderful thing called hindsight would surely suggest that winning three-in-a-row at Tannadice in May 2008 would have been the perfect time for Strachan to bow out unbeaten at Celtic.

The trials of Strachan and Middlesbrough will make interesting and detached viewing for Celtic supporters over the coming weeks and months.

Despite their league position they remain third favourites for promotion but even at odds of 20/1 there's unlikely to be a rush of money for 'Boro to finish the season as champions.

4 comments:

McAuley said...

Why don't you get off strachans back? I'm a celtic fan and he done a great job at celtic the last season went wrong but you can't blame the man. Now he's at middlesbrough and hasn't won yet, he can't turn it around just like that middlesbrough has an awful team adam johnson is the only exception.The reason he isn't playing well is because his mentors gone and he's in the championship that would be demoralising considering the boys ability.As for automatic promotion places "fading fast" it only takes a few wins to be back in there the league is that tight.This articals just anti-strachan.

Anonymous said...

Totally agree McAuley.
This article is just an excuse to have a go at GS.

A change of manager doesn't suddenly make your players better over night. I'm positive that WGS will do a tremendous job there once the players get used to the way he wants them to play.

He did a fantastic job at Celtic.

Give him a break ffs.

Joe McHugh said...

I don't think Strachan will be bothered by anyone's opinion other than his own.

He was a more successful Celtic manager than Martin O'Neill, a phrase that many Celtic fans find hard to admit to.

His last 12/18 months at Celtic were pretty poor, he galvanised the team to win eight on the bounce to win the league at Tannadice but either side of that there wasn't much to celebrate or enjoy.

The problems he encountered in the last five months of his time at Celtic seem to have resurfaced at Boro, how he deals with that is of interest to me and many Celtic supporters.

Anonymous said...

Well, I reckon Strachan has set back Celtic at least 5yrs, he has destroyed the club spirit, wrecked our signing policy and underachieved with HIS signings. His best season (facts) were due to MON players at his disposal.

If you plotted goals for, against, attendance and european coefficient (which he road on the back of MON points tally for seedings) you would get your answer.

I fail to see it any other way - just plain facts.

...still sore at his appointment.